(1)事实与程序:上诉人 R.S.-2 与 J.P. 就 Brooke County 巡回法院 2025-05-27 准许监护人 ad litem 变更处置、终止其对 R.S.-1 与 L.S. 父母权利的裁定提起上诉,主张初次处置后的程序瑕疵侵害其正当程序与获得律师帮助权等七项错误;州最高上诉法院认定巡回法院未满足 W. Va. Code § 49-4-604(c)(6) 的程序要求,「实质性无视并挫败」了处置程序,撤销并发回重审。(2)AI 引证认定:判决脚注 12 载明「Our consideration of the petitioners' arguments was hindered by the inaccurate citations to case law, statutes, and rules within the petitioners' brief, including a fabricated syllabus point and fictional quotations. Other courts have found similar anomalies indicative of the use of generative artificial intelligence ("AI") to draft court submissions.」——法院未直接认定律师使用 AI,而以「类似异常」的比较方式指出,并援引 2024-06-14 西弗州律师纪律委员会 Legal Ethics Opinion 24-01:律师有义务确保 AI 产出准确完整,违反可触及 Rule 1.1(能力)、Rule 3.3(对法庭坦诚)、Rule 4.1(对他人真实)。(3)监督义务扩张至「非人」协助者:脚注 12 引 LEO 24-01 指出,依 Rules 5.1 与 5.3,律师对协助提供法律服务的律师与**非律师**(原文「whether human or not」)负监督义务——即把 AI 工具置于与受监督的非律师辅助人员同一伦理框架。(4)横向比较与处置:脚注 12 列举 Williams v. Honl(Or. App. 2026,撤销书状、给 28 日重提并判付对方律师费)、Tov Realty v. Suarez(Conn. 2026,强制继续法律教育并向州律师协会基金捐款)、Prososki v. Regan(Neb. 2026,撤销书状、驳回上诉、移送纪律部门)、Garner v. Kadince(Utah App. 2025)、In re Baby Boy(Ill. App. 4th 2025)、Kruse v. Karlen(Mo. Ct. App. 2024)等制裁谱系,并明确「we remind all members of the legal profession that they remain personally responsible for verifying the accuracy of every citation, quotation, and statement of law submitted to the Court」;结论段落确认不排斥技术使用,但引用 ByoPlanet Int'l v. Johansson(792 F. Supp. 3d 1341, 1347 (S.D. Fla. 2025))要求律师确保生成的法律命题与权威「trustworthy」;末段依 Syl. Pt. 8, Gum v. Dudley(202 W. Va. 477, 505 S.E.2d 391 (1997))与 RPC Rule 8.3(a)、司法行为准则 Canon 3D(2),指令书记官将判决认证副本移送律师纪律办公室(Office of Disciplinary Counsel)审查,并声明移送不等于对是否应予纪律处分的预断。
核证:2026-11-14 核证:①L1 判决原文直下(courtswv.gov 官网 PDF HTTP 200,331,659 B,与 CourtListener 镜像同字节),pypdf 提取 24 页/42,302 字符,逐项比对案号(No. 25-425)、法院(Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia)、文印日期(Filed: November 12, 2026,released 3:00 p.m.)、主笔法官(JUSTICE KIRKPATRICK)、原审法院与三案号(Brooke County CC-05-2023-JA-24/25/28)、处置(Vacated and Remanded with Directions)与脚注 12 全文引文,均与官方文本一致,无幻觉案号;②纪律移送表述原文核验为「we direct the Clerk of the Supreme Court of Appeals to transmit a certified copy of this Opinion to the Office of Disciplinary Counsel」,并附「express no opinion as to whether disciplinary proceedings ultimately should be initiated」之保留;③本案未作出任何金钱制裁,入库表述未推定制裁结果;④AI 要素系法院主动在脚注 12 中提出的书状审查问题,构成裁判文书的实质内容(非仅侦查/背景事实),符合 AI 要素门槛;⑤与库内查重:全库无 West Virginia 州最高上诉法院 AI 条目,无 25-425 案号,无 A.S./R.S.-1/L.S. 当事人重复。分法域搜索智能体双审直入(法学专家〔美国〕视角+内容审核员视角)。